Sunday, January 8, 2012

BSWM

My friends and I recently formed a book club (I know...geeky, nerdy, whatever).  We're starting off with Black Skin, White Masks by Frantz Fanon.  I expect that this will be both a challenge for me and a joy.  A challenge because even though I am familiar with critical theory, I've had little experience with post-colonialism and psychoanalysis.  If approach well, I expect that this will be a growing experience.  A joy because I hope that this highly praised and important work will provide me more tools for thinking through current realities of racism and of contemporary forms of colonization.  Additionally, even as I read through the first chapter, I could identify some of his analyses in my own life, in my family, and in my work with the low income, black communities here in Washington, D.C.  I'll end this post with a terrific excerpt from his first chapter:

"All colonized people--in other words, people in whom an inferiority complex has taken root, whose local cultural originality has been committed to the grave--position themselves in relation to the civilizing language: i.e., the metropolitan culture.  The more the colonized has assimilated the cultural values of the metropolis, the more he will escape the bush.  The more he rejects his blackness and the bush, the whiter he will become.  In the colonial army, and particularly in the regiments of Senegalese soldiers, the 'native' officers are mainly interpreters.  They serve to convey to their fellow soldiers the master's orders, and they themselves enjoy a certain status."
-Frantz Fanon, Black Skin, White Masks, 2-3.

Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Grace & a quote by Martin Luther

"Behold, from faith thus flow forth love and joy in the Lord, and from love a joyful, willing, and free mind that serves one's neighbor willingly and takes no account of gratitude or ingratitude, of praise or blame, of gain or loss.  For a man does not serve that he may put men under obligations.  He does not distinguish betwen friends and enemies or anticipate their thankfulness or unthankfulness, but he most freely and most willingly spends himself and all that he has, whether he wastes all on the thankless or whether he gains a reward.  As his Father does, distributing all things to all men richly and freely, making 'his sun rise on the evil and on the good' [Matt. 5:45], so also the son does all things and suffers all things with that freely bestowing joy which is his delight when through Christ he sees it in God, the dispenser of such great benefits."

-Martin Luther, "The Freedom of a Christian Man"

In light of God's grace--frivolously and unconditionally given to all--the only appropriate response is to be gracious in our relationships with each another.  To be generous toward our friends and our enemies alike, to give without expectation and without engendering debt in others, and to live joyfully assured that there is enough for us all.

Tuesday, January 3, 2012

LGB...T?

For various reasons, some believe that Transgender movements should be separate from Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual movements.  Many of these reasons are valid and understandable.  However one reason that I've repeatedly heard is that LGB issues deal with sexuality while T issues relate to gender.  I find this reason completely unsatisfactory.  In my following reflections, I don't want to simply employ trans/gender/queer identities (I'm including Intersexed in this category) to the self-realization of LGB movements, however I do see a benefit to including discussions about gender among Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual communities.

First and foremost, as soon as the terms Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual are employed, aren't they already assuming and relying upon a gender framework?  Aren't they already making declarations--whether implicitly or explicitly--about sex and gender identities?  After all, can one really speak about lesbianism--woman to woman eroticism--without some definition or assumption about what "woman" means?  Whether one defines "woman" according to social constructions of gender performance or according to biological arrangements (sex), lesbianism loses all meaning without relying on a framework that gives definition to sex and/or gender.  Even bisexual, as it is currently understood, is built on the binary of sex/gender identity of male/female and man/woman. To speak of LGB issues at all means that statements regarding sex and gender have been made or assumed.

It's no secret that "Gay Rights" have gained much national attention to the neglect of Lesbian and Bisexual voices--a fact which reveals that much of "Gay Rights" discourses have done very little to challenge patriarchal structures.  In fact, the growing success Gay Rights can be attributed to our male-dominated society which still give men center stage.  However, trans/gender/queer identities present another challenge not only to "Gay Rights" but also to the very labels of Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual.  Terms such as trans/gender/queer remind us that the labels of Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual continue to play into binary systems that limit both gender identity and sexual idenity.

First, with regard to gender identity.  Gender identity is limited by LGB labels because it assumes that "male" and "female" are stable identities.  Trans/genderqueer expose the fact that gender identity is a construction that is always fluid and negotiated.  Gender identity is taught, learned, and performed at every moment in society--for example, when a woman shaves her legs or when a man shouts at the TV while watching a football game.  Even these performative cues and signs change depending on our changing, but particular, contexts--for example, it's effeminate for a man to cross his legs in some situations (i.e. at a sporting event), but it can communicate power in others (i.e. at a board meeting).  Despite the force of the hegemonic definitions of gender into the binary of man/woman, these definitions are not fixed--the have and continue to change.  Taking it further, even the biological stability of male/female is put into question by various factors.  It's shown to be malleable by modern medical/technological developments and ambiguous by those who are Intersexed.  Moreover, the fact that multiple biological factor are associated with sex development--not only a particular chromosome, but various other configurations such as the nuanced composition of that chromosome, testosterone/estrogen levels throughout the body, the presence/absence of certain glands--show that biological sexual identity come with many variables and variations even if they're not externally visible (see, for example, Klinefelter's syndrome).  These realities are not always taken into account by Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual movements.  These variables are overlooked by those who might be passionate about "Gay Rights" but still benefit and are comfortable with the prevailing hegemonic control of sex/gender identities.

But the trans/gender/queer movements also challenge LGB movements regarding erotic sexual identity (or "sexuality" or "sexual orientation") and this second challenge is related to the first.  Not only do Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual labels continue to accept fixed gender binaries, but they also limit sexual orientation to being object-based--that is, sexual identity is defined by the gender of the one by whom are aroused.  That is to say, in LGB movements, lesbianism is defined as Person A (a woman) being aroused by Person B who is also a woman; gay is defined because Person C (a man) is aroused by Person D who is also man.  In Sex and the Single Savior (see my entry about this text here), Dale Martin points out that sexual definitions in Greek antiquity were not merely object-based, but based on the sexual roles of penetrator and penetrated.  That is, it wasn't unusual to expect that a male would be aroused by both males and females, however it was proper that the man (if he's in good social standing and reputation) would be the pentrator.  The women and the (male) youth he sexually engaged would be penetrated--a role considered effeminate and unfit for an honorable man.  Sexuality was not simply defined by the sex/gender of one's arousal, but by the role(s) played by those engaged in sexual activities.  Don't get me wrong, this is still a sexist and oppressive framework, but it shows that erotic sexual identity does not have to be based of the sex/gender of the one who arouses us, rather it can be defined by other aspects which are part of sexual practices.  I believe trans/gender/queer identities can challenge Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual labels to recognize more aspects to sexuality or "sexual orientation" than gender identity.
 
To elaborate this further, why define erotic sexual identity based on the sex/gender of the one who arouses us?  There are many features that permeate our sexual lives and there's no reason to make one more determinative than others.  If we used a penetrator/penetrated framework, how then would we define heteroseuxal men who enjoy being fingered or being dildo-fucked by women (remember Road Trip)?  What would we say regarding homosexual men who only top and refuse to bottom or to be subjected to anal play?  What would we say of women who fingered/dildo-fucked each other, thereby constantly changing the position of penetrator/penetrated?  What if sexual identity was viewed along other lines such as those who enjoyed being dominant and those who enjoyed being submissive (after all, the categories of dominant/submissive are not synonymous with penetrator/penetrated)?  How would we think of aggressive male bottoms (power bottoms) or submissive tops?  Or supposed we made distinctions among those who were sexually monogamous and those who were polyamorous and those who are celibate (after all, celibacy can be queer, too)?  What's amazing is that these are all forms of sexual identification that do not rely on gender identity but reveal that sexuality as multifaceted--it is crisscrossed by multiple dimensions and factors.  To broaden our discussions of both gender identity and of sexuality creates space for mutually edifying contributions between Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual movements and Trans/gender/queer movements.  What's disappointing is the refusal of many "self-proclaimed progressive" "gay rights" voices to allow themselves to be challenged in their assumptions of gender and sexual identity.

A multitude of possible identities can be opened if Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual movements allow themselves to be challenged by Trans/gender/queer identities.  However, as I said earlier, I don't want to simply employ trans/gender/queer identities for the self-realization of Lesbian, Gay, & Bisexual people.  Movements in sex & gender activism have their own voice and need to speak on their own terms, not simply in the service of homo/bisexual movements.  As a cisgendered male, I continue to gain a lot from trans/gender/queer movements and am in solidarity with their struggles, but it would be another form of exploitation to merely use their identities for my own self-actualization.  Trans/genderqueer movements have an agency of their own and need to be heard on their own terms, but, personally, I would like to see that happen alongside LGB communities.

Monday, December 19, 2011

Origins of Evil

He posed to question to me: "Where do you think it comes from?  Evil, where does it come from?"  My boyfriend wasn't referring to the catastrophes and illnesses that behalf all of us (more or less), but to what many have called "moral evil."  He was referring to the drive that has lead humans to create structures that favor few while depriving many, to build institutions that perpetuate the horrors of violence, to insatiably consume the earth's abundant resources and create unsustainable economies.  How did we become enslaved to a momentum that only seems to multiply the cruelties in the world?  What's the origin that gives rise to enslaving black bodies and dispossessing American Indians?  Or to violence against women or to totalitarian regimes?  Or to exploitation and economic inequality?  What's the source of [moral] evil?

There's no answer to this question.  No psychology, history, or philosophy has or can adequately answer this question.  And, despite our interpretations, the Bible doesn't pretend to give answer to this question either.  By definition, evil is meaningless and without rationality.  This is the case even in instances when evil can be executed by highly rational and precise movements--for example in the Holocaust, war, or slavery.  Many of these executions of evil are very strategic and justify themselves by use of science, political theory, or some other discipline.  But the reason for the evil--why such conditions are brought about--remains beyond reason.  It's my belief, however, that the non-rationality of evil can only be rivaled by the non-rationality of grace and the madness of faith that it commands.  The meaninglessness of cruelty that lies beyond all logic can only be overcome by a grace that exceeds all calculation or horizons.  And those who respond to that grace in faith, respond with a generosity that can only appear as madness.

Monday, December 12, 2011

"Land of the free, home of the hungry"

Always insightful and bold, Gary Younge's articles in the Guardian's Comment is Free section are terrific commentaries on America's social realities.  He often times addresses sensitive matters carefully while not shying from strong statements against commonly held opinions.  Check out his latest article about poverty, food stamps, and the Republican aspirations "to balance the budget on the stomachs of the hungry."

Wednesday, December 7, 2011

The Joy of Being Wrong by James Alison

Book recommendation:  The Joy of Being Wrong by James Alison.  Once the opening pages grabbed me, it didn't take me too long to burn through this one.  In this book, Alison relies on RenĂ© Girard's theories of mimetic desire and the scapegoat mechanism to shine new light on the New Testament witness.  His most important contribution through this book is his insistence that theology must begin with the Resurrection of Christ, which is the key to understanding salvation, theological anthropology, and original sin.  Not only is the resurrection the moment when our salvation is revealed, but it's also the moment when our sin is made known, as well.  In being forgiven, that which we are being forgiven of is made known, namely, our complicity in violence and exclusion.  Though I cringed at a few places throughout this work, the insights offered are very rich and well worth the journey.

"Al human sociality is born thanks to the victim, and particularly, to ignorance of the victim(s) that gave it birth.  Human language and thought are already utterly inflected by this ur-violence from their conception."
-James Allison, The Joy of Being Wrong, 16.


"The risen Jesus did not need to say to those who had run away, 'I forgive you': his presence to them was a forgiving presence, was forgiveneness as a person.  So in Luke and John he gives them power and commands them to forgive others as the way of spreading this presence dynamically in human form.  To the disciples themselves the very fact of his gratuitous presence was forgiveness."
-James Allison, The Joy of Being Wrong, 75.

"Sin is recast entirely in the light of the casting out of Jesus... Sin is revealed a the mechanicism of expulsion which is murderous, and those are blind sinners who are involved in that mechanism without being aware of what they're doing."

-James Allison, The Joy of Being Wrong, 122.

Thursday, December 1, 2011

Eros and Pseudo-Dionysius

I am moved when I read the great Christian theologian, Pseudo-Dionysius.  For him God is the transcendent and overflowing Good which surpasses all intelligibility and form--even surpassing Being-itself.  The Good is the source of all things, gives light to all, and sets all things in motion with erotic (yes, erotic!) yearning for the Good.  I find the lure of Pseudo-Dionysius in this:  rather than seeing the universe as simply ordered by static forms, or as governed by cold rationality and mechanic movement, or as a threatening chaos that has to be mastered (for example, consider the modernity), Pseudo-Dionysius sees the entire universe as fundamentally erotic--propelled and drawn by superabundant desire that overflows to beings and non-beings alike.

Pseudo-Dionysius is adamant that all things in the universe (celestial, human, inanimate and otherwise) are moved by God to desire and all things desire God.  Then, bucking against his Neoplatonic inclinations, the theologian affirms that, in God's excess, God erotically yearns for all things.  Then, he takes yet another step to assert that God is not only the foundation and the object of our desire, but God is desire itself in motion.  We don't have to accept all the Neoplatonic trappings to benefit from this joyous and erotic theology.

"And we may be so bold as to claim also that the Cause of all things loves all things in the superabundance of his goodness, that because of this goodness he makes all things, brings all things to perfection, holds all things together, returns all things.  The divine longing is Good seeking good for the sake of the Good.  That yearning (eros) which creates all the goodness of the world preexisted superabundantly within the Good and did not allow it to remain without issue."
-Pseudo-Dionysius, Divine Names, Ch. 4.10

"This divine yearning (eros) brings ecstasy so that the lover belongs not to self but to the beloved... And, in truth, it must be said too that the very cause of the universe in the beautiful, good superabundance of his benign yearning for all is also carried outside of himself in the loving care he has for everything.  He is, as it were, beguiled by goodness, by love, and by yearning and is enticed away from his transcendent dwelling place and comes to abide within all things, and he does so by virtue of his supernatural and ecstatic capacity to remain, nevertheless, within himself... In short, both the yearning and the object of that yearning belong to the Beautiful and the Good."
-Pseudo-Dionysius, Divine Names, Ch. 4.13

"He is yearning on the move, simple, self-moved, self-acting, preexistent in the Good, flowing out from the Good onto all that is and returning once again to the Good."
-Pseudo-Dionysius, Divine Names, Ch. 4.14