Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Modernity and the Holocaust by Zygmunt Bauman

Zygmunt Bauman had already grabbed my attention when I read his phenomenal work, Liquid Modernity; now I've picked up one of his more celebrated works, Modernity and the Holocaust.  Bauman's text exhibits profound insight, critical analysis and development, along with amazing accessibility (which helps initiate a broad readership into very complex ideas).  Below are just a few passages from this text:

Regarding bureaucracy and the suppression of moral capacity.

"Dehumanization is inextricably related to the most essential, rationalizing tendency of modern bureaucracy... Once effectively dehumanized, and hence cancelled as potential subjects of moral demands, human objects of bureaucratic task-performance are viewed with ethical indifference..."(Zygmunt Bauman, Modernity and the Holocaust, 103)


And, on survivor's guilt and the indissolubility of  moral responsibility, Bauman writes:

"One story, however, carved itself into my brain deeply and haunted me for many years.  This was a story of a saintly sage who met a beggar on the road while traveling with a donkey loaded with sackfuls of food.  The beggar asked for something to eat.  'Wait,' said the sage, 'I  must first untie the sacks.' Before he finished the unpacking, however, the long hunger took its toll and the beggar died.  Then the sage started his prayer: 'Punish me, o Lord, as I failed to save the life of my fellow man!'...

.... Even if one knows that not much more could have been done practically to save the victims of the Holocaust (at least not without additional, and probably formidable, costs), this does not mean that moral qualms can be put to sleep.  Nor does it mean that a moral person's feeling of shame is unfounded (even if its irrationality in terms of self-preservation can be, indeed, easily proved)."(204)

This is an incredible book and I highly recommend it for anyone of us who are still caught up in the myths of modernity: progress, rationality, objectivity, and the supremacy of science.  He argues that modernity is the necessary condition, though not the determinative factor, for the Holocaust to have taken place.  In fact, the Holocaust is a demonstration of modernity's power, not modernity's failure.  He exposes contemporary racism as a thoroughly modern project (even though there were prejudices and forms of segregation in the past, racism as it is understood today has its roots in the modern project).  The emergence of racism coupled with guided by the principles of progress and the belief of social engineering lead to frightening results.  It was the The modern bureaucratic machine--in its division of labor, suppression of morality capacities, and cost-effecitve rationality--that enabled the Holocaust enlist "normal" citizen into carrying out the final solution.  Again, this book comes with my approval.

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

Cost of Discipleship by Dietrich Bonhoeffer

I'm nothing short of impressed by Dietrich Bonhoeffer.  In Cost of Discipleship, he moves through the Sermon on the Mount and other teachings of Christ in the Gospel of Matthew--commenting on their implications for the Christian believer.  At every turn he reminds the reader that the life of discipleship is a costly one which puts the believer in sole reliance upon the Word of God.  The Word alone is the disciple's source of identity and direction which moves the disciple through a hostile world.  And the Word of God is nothing the believer possesses as his own, rather the Word of God both judges the disciple and calls the disciple to obedience.  Bonhoeffer is clear that our pretenses to take refuge in our efforts, in our self-recognition, or virtue are all overturned by the Word which calls us to discipleship, but our security and reward are established in Christ who is "for us" without being ours to own.  "Of course the righteousness of the disciples can never be a personal achievement; it is always a gift, which they received when they were called to follow him." (125)  For Bonhoeffer, discipleship consists of single-minded obedience--undivided and unswearving faithfulness to Jesus in his suffering.


There are a few times when I think Bonhoeffer would make a good Anabaptist, especially in his chapters addressing revenge and love of enemies.  In the former, he reflects on Jesus' command to "Resist not evil" (Matt. 5:38-42).  Here he explicitly opposes the traditional interpretation of this passage offered by Reformers who distinguished between the evil suffered by the person as such and the evil suffered as one who holds a public office.  For the Reformers, the call to "resist not evil" only applies to the evil suffered personally, but it does not apply to instances when one suffers evil while holding an ordained office.  For example, according to the Reformers, Jesus' commandment of nonviolence applies to the individual who is mugged and beaten while strolling through the city, but it does not apply to the judge or the military officer who oppose criminals and foreign enemies with violence.  Bonhoeffer writes:

"The distinction between person and office is wholly alien to the teachings of Jesus.  He says nothing about that.  He addresses his disicples as men who have left allto follow him, teh precept of non-violence applies equally to private life and official duty.  He is the Lord of all life, and demands undivided allegiance." (143).

And, in addition to evoking the sovereignty of Christ over the life of the believer, Bonhoeffer also explains the difficulty found in such a distinction between private life and the public sphere.

"Am I ever acting only as a private person or only in an official capacity?  If I am attacked am I not at once the father of my children, the pastor of my flock, and e.g. a government official?  Am I not bound for that very reason to defend myself against every attack, for reason of responsibility to my office?" (143).

By removing the distinction between the private and the public sphere, by understanding that Jesus' commandment to nonviolence remains no matter the capacity in which the individual acts, Bonhoeffer makes a move in an Anabaptist direction which rejected Luther's claim that Christians must live in the two kingdoms--that of the world and that of the Church.

Moreover, in accordance with themes of the Anabaptist tradition, Bonhoeffer sees the call to love one's enemies, not as an unrealistic command where, by issuing it, our ethical limitations are revealed.  He again refuses to make the distinction between acting in a private vs. public capacity.  Rather, "love is defined in uncompromising terms as the love of our enemies," (146). He also writes, "Christian love draws no distinction between one enemy and another, except that the more bitter our enemy's hatred, the greater his need of love," (148).  While he ultimately refuses to make the leap into the Anabaptst pool, he reads his Lutheran tradition with a lens that refuses to allow Christians to live comfortably in the kingdom of the world, challenges them to nonviolence, and demands full adherence to the teachings of Christ in the total life of the believer.  Our remaining in the world in our worldly capacities is depended on the degree to which our worldly duties and obligations are in alignment/conflict with the call to obedience.

Finally, for Bonhoeffer, discipleship means nothing less than suffering and being joined to Christ's suffering.  For Bonhoeffer, suffering is the result of the self-renunciation demanded by the call upon our lives by the Word.  We suffer as we give up the securities of worldly peace, dignity, self-assertion, or guarantees to life.  However, suffering is not only necessary for embarking upon the life of faith, it is the very mark of discipleship.  Suffering is the Christians' response to evil and suffering is found on the cross as the extraordinary: the place where unconditional love for one's enemies is made present.  He even writes:

 "Discipleship means allegiance to the sufferings of Christ, and it is therefore not at all surprising that Christians should be called upon to suffer.  In fact it is a joy and a token of his grace.  The acts of the early Christian martyrs are full of evidence which shows how Christ transfigures for his own the hour of their mortal agony by granting them the unspeakable assurance of his presence.  In the hour of the cruellest torture they bear for his sake, they are made partakers in the perfect joy and bliss of fellowship with him.  To bear the cross proves to be the only way of triumphing over suffering." (91)

This is his only text I've read so far, but I found a few themes lacking in his discussion of discipleship, particularly the Spirit and the resurrection.  The Spirit gets brief mention during his chapters on ecclesiology, but isn't the power the Spirit central to the life of the individual disciple?  Similarly, what is the role of the resurrection in the life of the disciple?  Eventually, Bonhoeffer mentions explicitly, yet in passing, what is, in fact, essential to the entire discussion of suffering and discipleship:

"But between the death of Christ and the apostolic gospel of the cross there lay the resurrection, which alone gives the cross its redemptive power.  The gospel of Christ crucified is always the gospel of him who was not held by death." (276)

The resurrection must always be present whenever Christians look to the cross, contemplate suffering, and think upon their own call to suffer.  Without it, as Bonhoeffer eventually mentions, the Good News isn't good news at all.

Monday, April 11, 2011

HELEM

"You can't have a position related to LGBT rights without fighting for everyone's rights. You can't be just against homophobia; you have to be against all discrimination and link these all together."

The LGBT struggle in Lebanon


I loved reading this article when it was first published on the Socialist Worker!  There is so much that LGBT activists in the West can learn from the vision and the social consciousness expressed in this article.  This article interviews Ghassan Makarem, the Executive Director of HELEM--a Lebanese organization which struggles for LGBTIQ liberation.  Their work is varied and broad--providing services, promoting action against discrimination, and refusing to trample on other demographics for the rights of their own.  There are far too many organizations here in the U.S. which separate their causes from the struggles of others--there are struggles for black communities, for women's rights, for disability rights, gay rights, etc.  Rather than [net]working together in mutual support, they often take a market-type approach of trying to convince (almost advertize to) "the public" that their cause is the most important, most dire, and most fundamental source of our current crises.  In this way, these organizations imitate popular business practices rather than working for holistic change.  What can we, in the West, learn from HELEM?

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Gentrification in DC

I'm indebted to my friend for bringing my attention to the article "DC, Long 'Chocolate City,' Becoming More Vanilla."

This story follows a trend that has happened to numerous Washington, DC neighborhoods--Adams Morgan and Columbia Heights; Petworth is already in the works.  Anacostia is the latest, but not the last, in DC's eastward march of gentrification--enjoyed by hipsters and ladder-climbing suburbanites alike (sadly, that includes me, too).  This article touches upon two very important issues, but fails to distinguish them well enough to make clear the problem at hand.  The title leads one to believe that the problem is primarily a racial matter--a predominantly black city is gaining more white inhabitants and losing it's long standing black residents.  Even though this is true, this covers over the fact that this is primarily a problem about economics and class rather than a racial issue.

Economics and race are inseparably intertwined, however they are NOT identical--and this fact makes all the difference.  First of all, the problem the article highlights is that poor families who have lived in DC are being displaced by rising property values and the increase in the cost of living because white developers are buying property, refurnishing old homes, and opening new businesses in low-income neighborhoods.  That is the problem of gentrification.  Secondly, this also has strong racial component because Washington, DC's has had an overwhelming black population.  This has been the case for at least three reasons, if not more: 1. a disproportionate percentage of poor people are black (one reason why race and economics are intimately tied), 2. many black people who moved from the South in the early 20th century settled in the city, AND 3. white flight in the late 60's created a city abandoned to the poor black populations.  This is an important distinction because the problem is not the presence or lack thereof of black people, but of the poor families who are being pushed out of their neighborhoods.  Therefore, whether the developers and new inhabitants are black or white does not make a difference, the injustice is that poor are being uprooted by the rich.  However, if anyone has an awareness of systemic racial injustice, it will be clear that the majority of the residents of Anacostia are poor black people and a majority of the developers are white.  Economic problems have strong racial implications and discussions about race are never unrelated to economic disparity.  However, if one will do justice to this problem, it must be seen primarily as an economic problem, not a racial matter.

I admit that I am puzzled by consequences of gentrification (actually, displacing the poor is not just a "consequence" of gentrification, but is directly at the heart of gentrification's intent).  Poor neighborhoods are complex systems filled with various relationships and patterns--good and some harmful.  In a poor neighborhood, there are families which care for its members, there are schools with networks of friends, familiar faces in churches and local stores.  These are healthy and vibrant relationships which have found their home in places like Anacostia.  However, there are also brutal gangs which divide the neighborhood into territories of violence and hostility.  There are drugs and prostitution circles--both of which are frequently used to keep people in dehumanizing servitude to others.  The truth is that poor families do not want to live in fear of violence any more than rich families do.  Poor or rich, no parent wants their child's life to be in danger simply by walking to school.  No one wants their sense of security violated by rape, muggings, or burglary.  Even though, I want to advocate for those who are poor, I find these ills hard to ignore--ills which have a direct correlation to burden and persistence poverty.  Unfortunately, the rich continue to believe that they know what the poor need and then, with clear consciences and deaf ears, impose their good works on those who already suffer the most.  Gentrification is the inadequate answer of the rich to the problems of poverty.

Let's not romanticize areas like Anacostia--fear of these areas are not solely a matter of white delusions about predominantly black neighborhoods.  There IS violence and high crime rates in this and other neighborhoods.  I do not want to displace those who are impoverished, but they live do in neighborhoods that are in need of transformation.  But what is needed? Better schools?  Community centers?  The removal of power plants and waste sites--causes of numerous health problems among the poor?  Better police enforcement (I know this would also demand an overall of the justice system and reducing instances of police corruption and brutality.  However, we must remember that despite instances of police brutality, some times the problem is that the police do not show up when needed by those who are live in these areas)?  Is there are a way to remove the ills of poor neighborhoods without uprooting multi-generational family and its beautiful communities?  Some of these communities stand like aged Sequoias in DC's transient population.  Until those who are poor--who have been historically poor--are the guidepost for our actions, then we have yet to do justice.

And how about us suburbanites--black, white, or any other race/ethnicity?  Where do we live and what do we do?  Some with good intentions (some with not-so-good intentions) have moved to these gentrified areas.  But the fact of the matter, whether we like it or not, is that simply our presence can send property value soaring and our neighbors shoved into the streets.  My friend reminds [and challenges] me that where one chooses to live is an ethical matter and I'm still struggling with what that will mean for me.